Home »
Ikhtalafi Masa'il
,
NAMAZ (SALAAH)
,
NAMAZ ME HATH KAHA BANDHNA
» NAMAZ ME HATH CHORNA - SHIA KI NAMAZ HAQ BAT SABKE SATH
NAMAZ ME HATH CHORNA - SHIA KI NAMAZ HAQ BAT SABKE SATH
ASSLAMUILEKUM WA RAHAMTULLAHE WA BARKATU
MASLA :- NAMAZ ME HATH CHORNA SAHABI SE SABIT HE
HADITH NO. 1
AATA BIN ABI RABAH KO NAMAZ PADTE DEKHA UNHONE
NAMAZ KE SURU ME ,
RAQU JATE,
RAQU SE APNA SIR UTHATE ,
RAFA-UL-YADAIN KARTE THE
KISI NE PUCHA AAP NE YE KAHA SE SIKHA
ATTA BIN ABI RABAH NE KAHA MENE
ABDULLAH BIN ZUBAIR SE SIKHA OR
ABDULLAH BIN ZUBAIR NE KAHA THA MENE APNE NANA JI
ABU BAKAR SIDEEQ R.D.H. OR UNHONE
NABI-E-KARIM RASUALLAH KE KO NAMAZ ESE PADHTE DEKHA
SUNNAN AL KUBRA AL BAHAHQI HADITH NO. 2519 ( SANAD SAHIH )
BY SHAIKH ZUBAIR ALI ZAI OR SHAIKH ALBANI
" YE GOLDER CHAIN YE SABIT KARTI HE KI ABDULLAH BIN ZUBAIR KI NAMAZ NABI KI NAMAZ HE "
HADITH NO. 2
Imam Maimoon Makki rh. se riwayat he ki mene
ABDULLA BIN ZUBAIR ko namaz padhte dekha inhone namaz padhai
Jab namaz suru kiya
RAQU jate wakt
RAQU se apna sir uthate wakt
jab sajde se apna sir uthaate
RAFA-UL-YADAIN karte
Mene jakar ye baat IBN ABBAS se pucha ki mene ABDULLAH BIN ZUBAIR ko dekha jo kisi ko karte nhi dekha
to IBN ABBAS ne kaha
AGER TUME RASULLLAH KI NAMAZ DEKHNI HE TO ABDULLAH BIN ZUBAIR KI NAMAZ DEKHO
ABU DAWOOD HADITH NO . 739 SAHIH BY SHAIKH ALBANI
NOTE:-" ( NOT AVBL. ON -ISLAM360 ) (READ BOOKS AND SUNNAH.COM AND MORE )
ABDULLAH BIN ZUBAIR NAMAZ SE RAFUL-YADAIN KI DALEEL OR HADITH SE WAJEH HONA KI UNKI NAMAZ NABI KI NAMAZ HE
HADITH NO. 3
HAJRAT IBNE ZUBAIR R.A. NAMAZ ME HATH KHOL KAR NAMAZ PADHTE THE
MUSSNAF IBNE ABHI SHIBA HADITH NO .3950 (3971) SANAD SAHIH
MUSSNAF IBNE ABHI SHIBA ME IMAM SHIBA NE PURA BAAB BANDHA HE
IKHTELAF:-ISH HADITH ME SIRF ITNA LIKHA HE NAMAZ ME HATH CHORTE THE ISH SE SAHIH SE SABIT NHI HOTA PURI HADITH NHI HE OR NA HI KOI DUSHRI HADITH HE SAHIH
MASLA :- NAMAZ ME HATH CHORNA SAHABI SE SABIT HE
HADITH NO. 1
AATA BIN ABI RABAH KO NAMAZ PADTE DEKHA UNHONE
NAMAZ KE SURU ME ,
RAQU JATE,
RAQU SE APNA SIR UTHATE ,
RAFA-UL-YADAIN KARTE THE
KISI NE PUCHA AAP NE YE KAHA SE SIKHA
ATTA BIN ABI RABAH NE KAHA MENE
ABDULLAH BIN ZUBAIR SE SIKHA OR
ABDULLAH BIN ZUBAIR NE KAHA THA MENE APNE NANA JI
ABU BAKAR SIDEEQ R.D.H. OR UNHONE
NABI-E-KARIM RASUALLAH KE KO NAMAZ ESE PADHTE DEKHA
SUNNAN AL KUBRA AL BAHAHQI HADITH NO. 2519 ( SANAD SAHIH )
BY SHAIKH ZUBAIR ALI ZAI OR SHAIKH ALBANI
HADITH NO. 2
Imam Maimoon Makki rh. se riwayat he ki mene
ABDULLA BIN ZUBAIR ko namaz padhte dekha inhone namaz padhai
Jab namaz suru kiya
RAQU jate wakt
RAQU se apna sir uthate wakt
jab sajde se apna sir uthaate
RAFA-UL-YADAIN karte
Mene jakar ye baat IBN ABBAS se pucha ki mene ABDULLAH BIN ZUBAIR ko dekha jo kisi ko karte nhi dekha
to IBN ABBAS ne kaha
AGER TUME RASULLLAH KI NAMAZ DEKHNI HE TO ABDULLAH BIN ZUBAIR KI NAMAZ DEKHO
ABU DAWOOD HADITH NO . 739 SAHIH BY SHAIKH ALBANI
NOTE:-" ( NOT AVBL. ON -ISLAM360 ) (READ BOOKS AND SUNNAH.COM AND MORE )
ABDULLAH BIN ZUBAIR NAMAZ SE RAFUL-YADAIN KI DALEEL OR HADITH SE WAJEH HONA KI UNKI NAMAZ NABI KI NAMAZ HE
LEKIN JESE HI UNKI HATH KHOL KAR NAMAZ PADNE KI HADITH AATI HE TO FIRQAPARASTI DIKHI HE LOGO ME
HADITH NO. 3
HAJRAT IBNE ZUBAIR R.A. NAMAZ ME HATH KHOL KAR NAMAZ PADHTE THE
MUSSNAF IBNE ABHI SHIBA HADITH NO .3950 (3971) SANAD SAHIH
MUSSNAF IBNE ABHI SHIBA ME IMAM SHIBA NE PURA BAAB BANDHA HE
IKHTELAF:-ISH HADITH ME SIRF ITNA LIKHA HE NAMAZ ME HATH CHORTE THE ISH SE SAHIH SE SABIT NHI HOTA PURI HADITH NHI HE OR NA HI KOI DUSHRI HADITH HE SAHIH
HO SAKTA HO YE HADITH RAQU KI HE YA QAYAM ALLAH BAHTAR JANTA HE
HADITH NO. 4
ABDULLAH BIN ZUBAIR NE FAMAYA KI DAYE HATH KO BAYE PER BANDHNA SUNNAT HE
SUNNAN ABI DAWOOD HADITH NO .754 SAHIH
NOTE :- JINKA ISHTEHAQ HE QAYAM ME HATH CHORNA ALLAH BAHTAR JANTA HE IS HADITH SE
HADITH NO. 4
ABDULLAH BIN ZUBAIR NE FAMAYA KI DAYE HATH KO BAYE PER BANDHNA SUNNAT HE
SUNNAN ABI DAWOOD HADITH NO .754 SAHIH
NOTE :- JINKA ISHTEHAQ HE QAYAM ME HATH CHORNA ALLAH BAHTAR JANTA HE IS HADITH SE
OR JO HATH BANDHNE KE KAYAL HE UNKE PASS BAHUT HADITH HE DAYE HATH KO BAYE HATH PER RAKHNA
ALLAH BAHTAR JANTA HE
-----------------------------------------------------------------
BAHUT SE TAIBAN NAMAZ ME HATH CHOR KE PADHTE THE
MUSSNAF IBNE ABHI SHIBA HADITH NO .3939 (3970) TO 3954 (3974)
HAJRA HASAN
HARJRAT IBRAHIM
HAJRA IBNE AON
HAJRAT IBNE SIREEN
HAJRAT ABDULLAH BIN YAZEED
HAJRAT SAYYED BIN MUSEED
HAJRAT ABDULLAH BIN IZZAR
HAJRAT SAYYED BIN ZUBAIR NE TO MAKKA ME EK AADMI KO HATH BANDH KE NAAMZ PADHTE DEKHA TO UNKE HATH HI KHOL DIYE
MUSSNAF IBNE ABHI SHIBA HADITH NO .3954 (3974)
IMAM MALIK KI FIQ KI KITAB ME BHI NAMAZ WALE CHAPTER ME
IMAM MALIK SE SAWAL JAWAB
IMAM MALIK NE FAMAYA FARZ NAMAZ ME HATH CHOR KE PADNI CHAHIYE
AGER NAFLI NAMAZ LAMBI HO JAYE TO JAWAS KI TAHAT HATH BAND LIYA JAYE
AL MUDAVN TUL KUBRA
-----------------------------------------------------------------
BAHUT SE TAIBAN NAMAZ ME HATH CHOR KE PADHTE THE
MUSSNAF IBNE ABHI SHIBA HADITH NO .3939 (3970) TO 3954 (3974)
HAJRA HASAN
HARJRAT IBRAHIM
HAJRA IBNE AON
HAJRAT IBNE SIREEN
HAJRAT ABDULLAH BIN YAZEED
HAJRAT SAYYED BIN MUSEED
HAJRAT ABDULLAH BIN IZZAR
HAJRAT SAYYED BIN ZUBAIR NE TO MAKKA ME EK AADMI KO HATH BANDH KE NAAMZ PADHTE DEKHA TO UNKE HATH HI KHOL DIYE
MUSSNAF IBNE ABHI SHIBA HADITH NO .3954 (3974)
IMAM MALIK KI FIQ KI KITAB ME BHI NAMAZ WALE CHAPTER ME
IMAM MALIK SE SAWAL JAWAB
IMAM MALIK NE FAMAYA FARZ NAMAZ ME HATH CHOR KE PADNI CHAHIYE
AGER NAFLI NAMAZ LAMBI HO JAYE TO JAWAS KI TAHAT HATH BAND LIYA JAYE
AL MUDAVN TUL KUBRA
NOTE :- IMAM MALIK RAFULYADAIN NHI KARTE WO BHI ISI KITAB ME LIKHA HE
ALHE HADITH ISH KITAB KO IMAM MALIK KI NHI MANTE ALLAH BAHTAR JANTA HE
HALAKI MUWATTA MALIK ME DAYA HATH BAYE HATH PER BANDHNA SUNNAT HE LEKIN
ALLAH BEHTAR JANTA HE
--------------------------------------------------------------
HAQ BAT SABKE SATH
1. NAMAZ ME HATH BANDHNA SUNNAT HE PURI POST DEKHE
https://zazaqallahh.blogspot.com/2020/01/namaz-me-hath-kaha-bandhna-naaf-ke.html
2. ABDULLAH BIN ZUBAIR KOI AAM SAHABI NHI HE LIHAZA JAIZ HE HATH BANDHNA ISH PER KOI FATWA NHI LAG SAKTA
3.SHIA HO YA SUNNI HAM SAB MUSLIM HE AAPAS ME PYAR SE RAHE MOHBBAT SE RAHE LADE NA
"NAMAZ KAYAM KARE ZAQAT DE FARZ ROZE RAKHE ALLAH HAM SAB KE GUNAH MAF KARE "
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
HALAKI MUWATTA MALIK ME DAYA HATH BAYE HATH PER BANDHNA SUNNAT HE LEKIN
ALLAH BEHTAR JANTA HE
--------------------------------------------------------------
HAQ BAT SABKE SATH
1. NAMAZ ME HATH BANDHNA SUNNAT HE PURI POST DEKHE
https://zazaqallahh.blogspot.com/2020/01/namaz-me-hath-kaha-bandhna-naaf-ke.html
2. ABDULLAH BIN ZUBAIR KOI AAM SAHABI NHI HE LIHAZA JAIZ HE HATH BANDHNA ISH PER KOI FATWA NHI LAG SAKTA
3.SHIA HO YA SUNNI HAM SAB MUSLIM HE AAPAS ME PYAR SE RAHE MOHBBAT SE RAHE LADE NA
"NAMAZ KAYAM KARE ZAQAT DE FARZ ROZE RAKHE ALLAH HAM SAB KE GUNAH MAF KARE "
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------